Return to the Utility Details

The Consolidated Case View displays the case information, actions taken on the case, and links to public documents associated with the case, which is identified by the Docket Number C-2011-2251178.

Case Summary

Docket Number C-2011-2251178 Closed
Applicant: Utility Code: 125146
Complainant: KATHLEEN MORAN-ROBERTO Utility Name: UGI Utilities, Inc. - Gas Division, North Rate District
Respondent: UGI PENN NATURAL GAS INC Utility Type: Gas
Responsible Bureau: ALJ Efiling Confirmation Number (Case):
Date Filed: 6/10/2011 Date Posted: 7/11/2011
Case Description: Kathleen Moran-Roberto vs. UGI Penn Natural Gas BCS: 2839495.    

Daily Actions

Action Date Description Posted Date
7/11/2011 Case Created - C-2011-2251178 - Formal complaint filed by Kathleen Moran-Roberto vs. UGI Penn Natural Gas. 7/11/2011
7/11/2011 Assigned Responsible Bureau - ALJ 7/11/2011
7/11/2011 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to ALJ, OTS. 7/11/2011
7/11/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'FC NOTICE' is made public 7/11/2011
7/11/2011 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Formal Complaint' Restricted on Web - {EC6ADF7F-83F8-444F-96A0-D4CDD1964680} 7/11/2011
7/11/2011 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Formal Complaint' is eServed - {EC6ADF7F-83F8-444F-96A0-D4CDD1964680} 7/11/2011
8/9/2011 Document Attached to Case - ANSWER & NEW MATTER - UGI PENN NATURAL VS ROBERTO - UGI Penn Natural Gas Co filed an answer to the formal complaint of Kathleen Moran-Roberto. 8/9/2011
8/9/2011 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'ANSWER & NEW MATTER - UGI PENN NATURAL VS ROBERTO' Restricted on Web - {2043B82A-3950-4FEB-A82B-889311A83745} 8/9/2011
8/17/2011 Document Attached to Case - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - OCA - OCA filed a notice of appearance of Dianne Dusman and Jennedy Johnson to the formal complaint of Kathleen Moran-Roberto vs UGI Penn Natural Gas. 8/17/2011
8/17/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - OCA' is made public 8/17/2011
8/18/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2011-2251178 IO.doc.docx' is made public 8/18/2011
8/18/2011 Document EServed to ServiceList - Document 'C-2011-2251178 IO.doc.docx' is eServed - {ABA74742-3366-4955-860F-09948818476F} 8/18/2011
10/11/2011 Document Attached to Case - NOTICE OF INTERVENTION - OCA - OCA filed a notice of intervention and public statement. 10/11/2011
10/11/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'NOTICE OF INTERVENTION - OCA' is made public 10/11/2011
10/13/2011 Document Attached to Case - Motion to Consolidate - OCA - Office of Consumer Advocate filed motion to consolidate 10/13/2011
10/13/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion to Consolidate - OCA' is made public 10/13/2011
10/14/2011 Document Attached to Case - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - UGI PENN NATURAL GAS VS ROBERTO - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed a notice of appearance to the formal complaint of Kathleen Moran-Roberto. 10/14/2011
10/14/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - UGI PENN NATURAL GAS VS ROBERTO' is made public 10/14/2011
10/19/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2011-2251178 et al Initial Hearing.doc' is made public 10/19/2011
10/19/2011 Document EServed to ServiceList - Document 'C-2011-2251178 et al Initial Hearing.doc' is eServed - {F6F2CF7E-E6BC-43A2-AF9C-E6EEED7C58E1} 10/19/2011
10/21/2011 Document Attached to Case - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - BIE - Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement filed a notice of appearance. 10/21/2011
10/21/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - BIE' is made public 10/21/2011
11/22/2011 Document Attached to Case - PREHEARING MEMO - OCA - OCA filed a prehearing memorandum. 11/22/2011
11/22/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'PREHEARING MEMO - OCA' is made public 11/22/2011
11/22/2011 Document Attached to Case - PREHEARING MEMO - UGI PENN NATURAL GAS - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed a prehearing memorandum to the formal complaint of Kathleen-Moran Roberto, et al. 11/22/2011
11/22/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'PREHEARING MEMO - UGI PENN NATURAL GAS' is made public 11/22/2011
12/1/2011 Document Attached to Case - Certificate of Service Interrogs Set I - OCA - OCA filed certificate of service to Interrogatories Set I 12/1/2011
12/1/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'Certificate of Service Interrogs Set I - OCA' is made public 12/1/2011
12/5/2011 Document Attached to Case - CERT OF SERVICE TO RESPONSES TO UGI PENN NATURAL GAS INTERROGS - OCA - OCA filed a certificate of service to the responses to Kathleen Moran-Roberto to UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc interrogatories and request for production of documents Set I. 12/5/2011
12/5/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'CERT OF SERVICE TO RESPONSES TO UGI PENN NATURAL GAS INTERROGS - OCA' is made public 12/5/2011
12/9/2011 Document Attached to Case - Transcript 11/28/11 Pre-Hrg Conf - Transcript of In-person/telephonic Pre-Hearing Conference w/ALJ Jandebeur held 11/28/11 at 10:00 am filed. 12/9/2011
12/9/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript 11/28/11 Pre-Hrg Conf' is made public 12/9/2011
12/13/2011 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Service to Obj OCA Interrogs Set I # 1 & 4-UGI Penn Natural Gas - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed certificate of service to objections to OCA Interrogatories Set I Nos. 1 & 4 12/13/2011
12/13/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Service to Obj OCA Interrogs Set I # 1 & 4-UGI Penn Natural Gas' is made public 12/13/2011
12/19/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2011-2251178 et al Initial & FurtherHearings.doc' is made public 12/19/2011
12/19/2011 Document EServed to ServiceList - Document 'C-2011-2251178 et al Initial & FurtherHearings.doc' is eServed - {3091D345-A0AE-40A2-9AAB-DCE6B867BC08} 12/19/2011
12/22/2011 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Svc Responses to OCA Interrogs Set I-UGI Penn Natural - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed Certificate of Service of responses to OCA Interrogatories Set I. 12/22/2011
12/22/2011 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Svc Responses to OCA Interrogs Set I-UGI Penn Natural' is made public 12/22/2011
1/20/2012 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Svc Direct Testimony M. Kraus OCA Stmt 1 - OCA - OCA filed Certificate of Service of Direct Testimony of Marilyn J. Kraus, OCA Statement 1 served to parties. 1/20/2012
1/20/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2011-2251178 Corrected Initial & Further Hearings.doc' is made public 1/20/2012
1/20/2012 Document EServed to ServiceList - Document 'C-2011-2251178 Corrected Initial & Further Hearings.doc' is eServed - {9F9E817C-2767-447B-A507-54D209D4E98D} 1/20/2012
1/20/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Svc Direct Testimony M. Kraus OCA Stmt 1 - OCA' is made public 1/20/2012
2/3/2012 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Svc Interrogs & Request Production Docs Set II on K. Moran-Roberto- UGI Penn Natural - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed Certificate of Service of Interrogatories & Request Production of Documents Propounded on Kathleen Moran-Roberto served to parties. 2/3/2012
2/3/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Svc Interrogs & Request Production Docs Set II on K. Moran-Roberto- UGI Penn Natural' is made public 2/3/2012
2/10/2012 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Service Rebuttal Testimony D Lahoff - UGI Penn Nat Gas - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed certificate of service to rebuttal testimony of David E Lahoff. 2/10/2012
2/10/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Service Rebuttal Testimony D Lahoff - UGI Penn Nat Gas' is made public 2/10/2012
2/17/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2011-2251178 Cancel Reschedule Initial & Further Hearings.doc' is made public 2/17/2012
2/17/2012 Document EServed to ServiceList - Document 'C-2011-2251178 Cancel Reschedule Initial & Further Hearings.doc' is eServed - {6068E64F-9850-47AF-B29F-25BDEC8CB45A} 2/17/2012
2/17/2012 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Svc of OCA Stmt S1 - OCA - OCA filed Certificate of Service of Surrebuttal Testimony of Marilyn J. Kraus, OCA Statement S1 served to parties. 2/17/2012
2/17/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Svc of OCA Stmt S1 - OCA' is made public 2/17/2012
3/8/2012 Document Attached to Case - CERT OF SERVICE TO INTERROGS - OCA - OCA filed a certificate of service to interrogatories. 3/8/2012
3/8/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'CERT OF SERVICE TO INTERROGS - OCA' is made public 3/8/2012
3/22/2012 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Service Response to OCA Interrogs Set II-PNG - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed certificate of service to responses to Interrogatories Set II of OCA. 3/22/2012
3/22/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Service Response to OCA Interrogs Set II-PNG' is made public 3/22/2012
4/20/2012 Document Attached to Case - TRANSCRIPT W/EXHIBS - MORAN ROBERTO VS UGI PENN NATURAL GAS CO - 4/5/12 - Kathleen Moran-Roberto vs UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc transcript with exhibits from hearing held on April 5, 2012 at 10:00AM. 4/20/2012
4/20/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'TRANSCRIPT W/EXHIBS - MORAN ROBERTO VS UGI PENN NATURAL GAS CO - 4/5/12' is made public 4/20/2012
4/20/2012 Document Attached to Case - TRANSCRIPT W/EXHIBS - MORAN ROBERTO VS UGI PENN NATURAL GAS CO - 4/6/12 - Kathleen Moran-Roberto vs UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc transcript w/exhibis from hearing held on April 6, 2012 at 9:00AM. 4/20/2012
4/20/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'TRANSCRIPT W/EXHIBS - MORAN ROBERTO VS UGI PENN NATURAL GAS CO - 4/6/12' is made public 4/20/2012
5/10/2012 Document Attached to Case - Briefs - OCA - OCA filed main brief. 5/10/2012
5/10/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Briefs - OCA' is made public 5/10/2012
5/17/2012 Document Attached to Case - Transcript Proposed Corrections - UGI & OCA - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc and the Office of Consumer Advocate filed Joint proposed corrections to hearing Transcript. 5/17/2012
5/17/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript Proposed Corrections - UGI & OCA' is made public 5/17/2012
5/31/2012 Document Attached to Case - Reply Briefs - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed Reply Brief 5/31/2012
5/31/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Briefs - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc' is made public 5/31/2012
6/6/2012 Document Attached to Case - Reply Briefs - Office of Consumer Advocate - Office of Consumer Advocate filed Reply Brief 6/6/2012
6/6/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Briefs - Office of Consumer Advocate' is made public 6/6/2012
9/12/2012 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - ID SERVED 9/12/12. EXCEPTIONS DUE 10/2/12. REPLIES DUE 10/12/12. 9/12/2012
9/12/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Kathleen Moran-Roberto et al v UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc ID' is made public 9/12/2012
9/14/2012 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Exceptions 9/14/2012
10/2/2012 Document Attached to Case - LTR stating no exception will be filed-BIE - BIE filed LTR that they will not be filing exceptions. 10/2/2012
10/2/2012 Document Attached to Case - Exceptions-OCA - OCA filed Exceptions. 10/2/2012
10/2/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'LTR stating no exception will be filed-BIE' is made public 10/2/2012
10/2/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions-OCA' is made public 10/2/2012
10/15/2012 Document Attached to Case - Reply Exception - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc filed Reply Exceptions 10/15/2012
10/15/2012 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Exception - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc' is made public 10/15/2012
5/13/2013 Document Attached to Case - Withdrawal of Appearance for OCA - D Dusman - Dianne E Dusman filed Withdrawal of Appearance on behalf of Office of Consumer Advocate. 5/13/2013
5/13/2013 Document Published on Web - Document 'Withdrawal of Appearance for OCA - D Dusman' is made public 5/13/2013
7/16/2013 Document Served - Other - See Comments 7/16/2013
7/16/2013 Document Published on Web - Document 'Opinion and Order - 2251178-OSA - 7-16-13 PM - Kathleen Moran-Roberto v UGI Penn Natural Gas - Exceptions to ID' is made public 7/16/2013
7/16/2013 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Opinion and Order - 2251178-OSA - 7-16-13 PM - Kathleen Moran-Roberto v UGI Penn Natural Gas - Exceptions to ID' is eServed - {A603E532-3668-4BFF-B2C3-ED15DE2BE12D} 7/16/2013
8/8/2013 Document Attached to Case - Entry of Appearance & Withdrawal of Appearance - Amy E Hirakis & Jennedy S Johnson - Jennedy S. Johnson, Assistant Consumer Advocate filed Withdrawal of Appearance and Entry of Appearance of Amy E. Hirakis, Assistant Consumer Advocate on behalf of Office of Consumer Advocate. 8/8/2013
8/8/2013 Document Published on Web - Document 'Entry of Appearance & Withdrawal of Appearance - Amy E Hirakis & Jennedy S Johnson ' is made public 8/8/2013

Public Documents

Document Name Document Type eFiling Confirmation Number Date Received Date Served Reference Docket Number
FC NOTICE Secretarial Letter BCS: 2839495
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - OCA Notice of Appearance 8/16/2011 BCS: 2839495
C-2011-2251178 IO.doc.docx Interim Order BCS: 2839495
NOTICE OF INTERVENTION - OCA Notice of Intervention 10/11/2011 BCS: 2839495
Motion to Consolidate - OCA Motion 10/13/2011 BCS: 2839495
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - UGI PENN NATURAL GAS VS ROBERTO Notice of Appearance 10/14/2011 BCS: 2839495
C-2011-2251178 et al Initial Hearing.doc Hearing Notice BCS: 2839495
NOTICE OF APPEARANCE - BIE Notice of Appearance 10/17/2011 BCS: 2839495
PREHEARING MEMO - OCA Prehearing Memorandum 11/21/2011 BCS: 2839495
PREHEARING MEMO - UGI PENN NATURAL GAS Prehearing Memorandum 11/21/2011 BCS: 2839495
Certificate of Service Interrogs Set I - OCA Certificate of Service 12/1/2011 BCS: 2839495
CERT OF SERVICE TO RESPONSES TO UGI PENN NATURAL GAS INTERROGS - OCA Certificate of Service 12/5/2011 BCS: 2839495
Transcript 11/28/11 Pre-Hrg Conf Transcript 12/2/2011 BCS: 2839495
Cert of Service to Obj OCA Interrogs Set I # 1 & 4-UGI Penn Natural Gas Certificate of Service 12/12/2011 BCS: 2839495
C-2011-2251178 et al Initial & FurtherHearings.doc Hearing Notice BCS: 2839495
Cert of Svc Responses to OCA Interrogs Set I-UGI Penn Natural Certificate of Service 12/21/2011 BCS: 2839495
C-2011-2251178 Corrected Initial & Further Hearings.doc Hearing Notice BCS: 2839495
Cert of Svc Direct Testimony M. Kraus OCA Stmt 1 - OCA Certificate of Service 1/20/2012 BCS: 2839495
Cert of Svc Interrogs & Request Production Docs Set II on K. Moran-Roberto- UGI Penn Natural Certificate of Service 2/3/2012 BCS: 2839495
Cert of Service Rebuttal Testimony D Lahoff - UGI Penn Nat Gas Certificate of Service 2/10/2012 BCS: 2839495
C-2011-2251178 Cancel Reschedule Initial & Further Hearings.doc Hearing Notice BCS: 2839495
Cert of Svc of OCA Stmt S1 - OCA Certificate of Service 2/17/2012 BCS: 2839495
CERT OF SERVICE TO INTERROGS - OCA Certificate of Service 3/7/2012 BCS: 2839495
Cert of Service Response to OCA Interrogs Set II-PNG Certificate of Service 3/22/2012 BCS: 2839495
TRANSCRIPT W/EXHIBS - MORAN ROBERTO VS UGI PENN NATURAL GAS CO - 4/5/12 Transcript 4/17/2012 BCS: 2839495
TRANSCRIPT W/EXHIBS - MORAN ROBERTO VS UGI PENN NATURAL GAS CO - 4/6/12 Transcript 4/17/2012 BCS: 2839495
Briefs - OCA Briefs 5/10/2012 BCS: 2839495
Transcript Proposed Corrections - UGI & OCA Case Related Document 5/14/2012 BCS: 2839495
Reply Briefs - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc Reply Briefs 5/30/2012 BCS: 2839495
Reply Briefs - Office of Consumer Advocate Reply Briefs 6/6/2012 BCS: 2839495
Kathleen Moran-Roberto et al v UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc ID Initial Decision 9/12/2012 BCS: 2839495
LTR stating no exception will be filed-BIE Letter 10/2/2012 BCS: 2839495
Exceptions-OCA Exceptions 10/2/2012 BCS: 2839495
Reply Exception - UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc Reply Exception 10/12/2012 BCS: 2839495
Withdrawal of Appearance for OCA - D Dusman Withdrawal Request 5/10/2013 BCS: 2839495
Opinion and Order - 2251178-OSA - 7-16-13 PM - Kathleen Moran-Roberto v UGI Penn Natural Gas - Exceptions to ID Order 7/16/2013 C-2011-2253878 et al
Entry of Appearance & Withdrawal of Appearance - Amy E Hirakis & Jennedy S Johnson Notice of Appearance 8/8/2013 C-2011-2253878 et al