Return to the Utility Details

The Consolidated Case View displays the case information, actions taken on the case, and links to public documents associated with the case, which is identified by the Docket Number C-2016-2537666.

Case Summary

Docket Number C-2016-2537666 Closed
Applicant: Utility Code: 110550
Complainant: CYNTHIA RANDALL & PAUL ALBRECHT Utility Name: PECO ENERGY COMPANY-ELECTRIC
Respondent: PECO ENERGY COMPANY Utility Type: Electric
Responsible Bureau: OSA Efiling Confirmation Number (Case): 1627784
Date Filed: 4/1/2016 Date Posted: 4/1/2016
Case Description: Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht v. PECO Energy Company    

Daily Actions

Action Date Description Posted Date
4/1/2016 Case Created - C-2016-2537666 - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht filed Formal Complaint vs PECO Energy Company. 4/1/2016
4/1/2016 Assigned Responsible Bureau - ALJ 4/1/2016
4/1/2016 Document Served - Other - See Comments - Assigned to ALJ, copy to BIE Prosecution. 4/1/2016
4/1/2016 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Formal Complaint' Restricted on Web - {541473EB-3E1B-4D31-AE22-4DADDE8E6108} 4/1/2016
4/1/2016 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Formal Complaint' is eServed - {541473EB-3E1B-4D31-AE22-4DADDE8E6108} 4/1/2016
4/21/2016 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Formal Complaint - PECO - PECO Energy Company filed Answer to Formal Compalaint of Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht. 4/21/2016
4/21/2016 Document Attached to Case - Preliminary Objection - PECO - PECO Energy Company filed Preliminary Objections. 4/21/2016
4/21/2016 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Formal Complaint - PECO' Restricted on Web - {9D804BC7-4EDF-48A5-ADE1-F57371785759} 4/21/2016
4/21/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Preliminary Objection - PECO' is made public 4/21/2016
5/2/2016 Document Attached to Case - Ans to POs-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht filed Ans to POs 5/2/2016
5/2/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Ans to POs-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 5/2/2016
5/11/2016 Document Attached to Case - Motion to Admit Counsel Thomas Carl Watson, Esq Pro Hac Vice for PECO - PECO Energy Company filed Motion to Admit Counsel Pro Hac Vice Thomas Carl Watson, Esquire. 5/11/2016
5/11/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion to Admit Counsel Thomas Carl Watson, Esq Pro Hac Vice for PECO' is made public 5/11/2016
5/11/2016 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Svc of Interrogs & Req Prod Of Docs Set I - PECO - PECO Energy Company filed Certificate of Service of Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents Set I. 5/11/2016
5/11/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Svc of Interrogs & Req Prod Of Docs Set I - PECO' is made public 5/11/2016
6/3/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall & Albrecht Motion Judge Assignment.doc' is made public 6/3/2016
6/3/2016 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall & Albrecht Motion Judge Assignment.doc' is eServed - {BC533DAB-D793-4FC9-A050-B361EE8A07A0} 6/3/2016
6/14/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Albrecht Randall v. PECO PO Order (3) REV.doc' is made public 6/14/2016
6/14/2016 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Albrecht Randall v. PECO PO Order (3) REV.doc' is eServed - {2FFB5D01-33B7-4757-9DCB-86A6FA867E2C} 6/14/2016
6/24/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'AlbrechtRandall PHO2 C-2015-2537666.doc' is made public 6/24/2016
6/24/2016 Document EServed to POR - Document 'AlbrechtRandall PHO2 C-2015-2537666.doc' is eServed - {1B10DDC9-9FB3-4636-ABA6-8BA57B6A641D} 6/24/2016
7/7/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666Hearing Notice' is made public 7/7/2016
7/7/2016 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666Hearing Notice' is eServed - {FA9C720D-2EC8-4390-8F70-5DD2223C6995} 7/7/2016
7/18/2016 Document Attached to Case - Letter of Expert Witnesses & Summary of Expert Witness Testimony - PECO - PECO Energy Company filed letter of Identification of Expert Witnesses and Summary of Expert Witness Testimony. 7/18/2016
7/18/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Letter of Expert Witnesses & Summary of Expert Witness Testimony - PECO' is made public 7/18/2016
8/5/2016 Document Attached to Case - Motion to Compel Answers to Discovery - PECO - PECO Energy Company filed Motion to Compel Answers to Discovery. 8/5/2016
8/5/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Motion to Compel Answers to Discovery - PECO' is made public 8/5/2016
8/9/2016 Document Attached to Case - Entry of Appearance-Harvey for Randall & Albrecht - Stephen G Harvey filed Entry of Appearance for Randall & Albrecht 8/9/2016
8/9/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Entry of Appearance-Harvey for Randall & Albrecht' is made public 8/9/2016
8/9/2016 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc Testimony & Exhibits - Randall & Albrecht - Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht filed Certificate of Service. 8/9/2016
8/9/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc Testimony & Exhibits - Randall & Albrecht' is made public 8/9/2016
8/9/2016 Document Attached to Case - Certificate of Service-PECO Energy Co - PECO Energy Co filed Certificate of Service 8/9/2016
8/9/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Certificate of Service-PECO Energy Co' is made public 8/9/2016
8/11/2016 Document Attached to Case - Answer to Motion-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht filed Answer to Motion 8/11/2016
8/11/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Answer to Motion-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 8/11/2016
8/11/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht Marino Order Denying Request For Deposition.doc' is made public 8/11/2016
8/11/2016 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht Marino Order Denying Request For Deposition.doc' is eServed - {74792F1A-9908-4B4B-B99B-7FCDF6DCF06B} 8/11/2016
8/15/2016 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Service-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht filed Cert of Service 8/15/2016
8/15/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Service-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 8/15/2016
8/16/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Joint Motion for Omnibus Schedule Revision - Peco & Complainants' is made public 8/16/2016
8/17/2016 Document Attached to Case - Request for Oral Deposition - PECO - PECO Energy Company filed Request for Oral Deposition. 8/17/2016
8/17/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Request for Oral Deposition - PECO' is made public 8/17/2016
8/29/2016 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc interrog set I - Randall & Albrecht - Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht filed Certificate of Service. 8/29/2016
8/29/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc interrog set I - Randall & Albrecht' is made public 8/29/2016
9/8/2016 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Svc of Answers to Discovery Set I Qs. 1-62 - PECO - PECO Energy Company filed Certificate of Service of Answers to Discovery Set I ,Qs. 1-62. 9/8/2016
9/8/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Svc of Answers to Discovery Set I Qs. 1-62 - PECO' is made public 9/8/2016
9/13/2016 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc witness list - Randall & Albrecht - Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht filed Certificate of Service. 9/13/2016
9/13/2016 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc witness list - Randall & Albrecht' is made public 9/13/2016
1/5/2017 Document Attached to Case - Electronic Transcript - Hrg 12-6-2016 (p 118-166) - Further Hearing with ALJ Darlene D. Heep and ALJ Christopher P. Pell held December 6, 2016 at 9:20 a.m. filed with exhibits. 1/5/2017
1/5/2017 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'Electronic Transcript - Hrg 12-6-2016 (p 118-166)' Restricted on Web - {D9197BE5-14C5-4D2A-8EC3-A5AECD7C8C42} 1/5/2017
3/24/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2015-2537666 Judge Change.docx' is made public 3/24/2017
3/24/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2015-2537666 Judge Change.docx' is eServed - {54C6CEA1-5FA4-4AAB-8B47-83F511E2853C} 3/24/2017
3/29/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Corrected Judge Change.docx' is made public 3/29/2017
3/29/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Corrected Judge Change.docx' is eServed - {27D2D229-B06B-4DDF-8AB3-BDD33F94503B} 3/29/2017
8/15/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Cynthia Randall Paul Albrecht v PECO Briefing Extension Heep.doc' is made public 8/15/2017
8/15/2017 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Cynthia Randall Paul Albrecht v PECO Briefing Extension Heep.doc' is eServed - {D23EB41D-C412-4CA5-A6E1-B194A222B680} 8/15/2017
9/26/2017 Document Attached to Case - Main Brief - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht filed Main Brief. 9/26/2017
9/26/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Main Brief - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 9/26/2017
10/2/2017 Document Attached to Case - Cover Pg & Certificate of Service to Main Brief - Complainant - Complainant filed cover page & certificate of service to Main Brief. 10/2/2017
10/2/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cover Pg & Certificate of Service to Main Brief - Complainant' is made public 10/2/2017
10/24/2017 Document Attached to Case - Main Brief - PECO Energy Co - PECO Energy Co filed Main Brief. 10/24/2017
10/24/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Main Brief - PECO Energy Co' is made public 10/24/2017
11/7/2017 Document Attached to Case - Reply Briefs - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht filed Reply Briefs. 11/7/2017
11/7/2017 Document Attached to Case - Cert of Srvc - Reply Brief of Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht filed certificate of service to Reply Brief 11/7/2017
11/7/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Briefs - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 11/7/2017
11/7/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Cert of Srvc - Reply Brief of Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 11/7/2017
11/14/2017 Document Attached to Case - Reply Briefs - PECO Energy Co - PECO Energy Company filed Reply Briefs. 11/14/2017
11/14/2017 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Briefs - PECO Energy Co' is made public 11/14/2017
3/16/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht v PECO Protective Order-Heep.docx' is made public 3/16/2018
3/16/2018 Document Removed from Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht v PECO Protective Order-Heep.docx' has been removed from Web 3/16/2018
3/16/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht v PECO Protective Order-Heep.docx' is made public 3/16/2018
3/16/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht v PECO Protective Order-Heep.docx' is eServed - {A6E9831D-F631-C801-853A-622FB8900000} 3/16/2018
3/20/2018 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - ID SERVED3/20/18, EXCEPTIONS DUE 4/9/18, REPLIES DUE 4/19/18 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht v PECO Energy Company ID NON-PROPRIETARY.pdf' Restricted on Web - {7A9895A6-3D8E-C603-8443-6243F4B00000} 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht v PECO Energy Company ID PROPRIETARY.pdf' Restricted on Web - {F010A748-952E-CDF9-8C04-6243F4C00000} 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 NON- PROPRIETARY ID SEC LTR.doc' is made public 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Private Document Published on Web - Document 'C-2016-2537666 PROPRIETARY ID SEC LTR.doc' Restricted on Web - {E7358724-72C0-CF2A-8945-62447C800000} 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht v PECO Energy Company ID NON-PROPRIETARY.pdf' is eServed - {7A9895A6-3D8E-C603-8443-6243F4B00000} 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht v PECO Energy Company ID PROPRIETARY.pdf' is eServed - {F010A748-952E-CDF9-8C04-6243F4C00000} 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 NON- PROPRIETARY ID SEC LTR.doc' is eServed - {FBF7303A-D9B9-CB62-85E9-62447AD00000} 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'C-2016-2537666 PROPRIETARY ID SEC LTR.doc' is eServed - {E7358724-72C0-CF2A-8945-62447C800000} 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document Served - Other - See Comments - CANCELLATION LETTER SERVED 3/20/18 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document Served & Pend - Pend for Exceptions - EXCEPTIONS DUE 4/9/18 - REPLIES 4/19/18 3/20/2018
3/20/2018 Document Served & Send to C&A - Other - See Comments - ID SERVED3/20/18, EXCEPTIONS DUE 4/9/18, REPLIES DUE 4/19/18 3/20/2018
3/22/2018 Document Attached to Case - Attach Document & Initiate Task - Pet for Ext Time to File Exceptions - Povacz 3/23/2018
3/23/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Pet for Ext Time to File Exceptions - Povacz' is made public 3/23/2018
3/23/2018 Document Attached to Case - Attach Document & Initiate Task - Letter request 20 day extension to file Exceptions - Stephen Harvey 3/23/2018
3/23/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Letter request 20 day extension to file Exceptions - Stephen Harvey' is made public 3/23/2018
3/26/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Secretarial Letter-Grants Extension of Time for Exceptions-C-2015-2475726 - C-2016-2537666 - C-2015-1475023-March 2018-Sunstein Murphy Randall and Albrecht and Povacz v PECO' is made public 3/26/2018
3/26/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Secretarial Letter-Grants Extension of Time for Exceptions-C-2015-2475726 - C-2016-2537666 - C-2015-1475023-March 2018-Sunstein Murphy Randall and Albrecht and Povacz v PECO' is eServed - {B3D9FBF8-0A9B-C547-8501-62637EF00000} 3/26/2018
4/20/2018 Document Attached to Case - Attach to Case - Petition for Extension of Time to File Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht 4/20/2018
4/20/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Petition for Extension of Time to File Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 4/20/2018
4/27/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Secretarial Letter-Grants 2nd Extension of Time for Exceptions-C-2015-2475726 - C-2016-2537666 - C-2015-1475023-April 2018-Sunstein Murphy Randall and Albrecht and Pova' is made public 4/27/2018
4/27/2018 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Secretarial Letter-Grants 2nd Extension of Time for Exceptions-C-2015-2475726 - C-2016-2537666 - C-2015-1475023-April 2018-Sunstein Murphy Randall and Albrecht and Pova' is eServed - {AECDAA0F-CA9E-C6EB-9582-630839900000} 4/27/2018
5/14/2018 Document Attached to Case - Attach to Case - Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht 5/14/2018
5/14/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 5/14/2018
5/15/2018 Document Attached to Case - Attach to Case - Letter - PECO Not Filing Exceptions 5/15/2018
5/15/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Letter - PECO Not Filing Exceptions' is made public 5/15/2018
6/5/2018 Document Attached to Case - Attach to Case - Reply Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht 6/5/2018
6/5/2018 Document Published on Web - Document 'Reply Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht' is made public 6/5/2018
5/9/2019 Document Served - Other - See Comments - ORDER ENTERED 5/9/19 5/9/2019
5/9/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Opinion and Order - 2537666-OSA - 5-9-19 PM - Exceptions - Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht v PECO.docx' is made public 5/9/2019
5/9/2019 Document EServed to POR - Document 'Opinion and Order - 2537666-OSA - 5-9-19 PM - Exceptions - Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht v PECO.docx' is eServed - {F9B32352-A848-CF66-847B-6A9C79000000} 5/9/2019
6/12/2019 Case Closed - No active tasks exist for this Case 6/12/2019
11/21/2019 Document Attached to Case - Transcript - Hrg 9-27-19 pg 11-44 and 52-72 CONFIDENTIAL 11/21/2019
11/21/2019 Document Attached to Case - Transcript - Hrg 9-27-16 pg 1-10 45-51 and 73-117 11/21/2019
11/21/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Transcript - Hrg 9-27-16 pg 1-10 45-51 and 73-117' is made public 11/21/2019
11/21/2019 Document Removed from Web - Document 'Transcript - Hrg 9-27-16 pg 1-10 45-51 and 73-117' has been removed from Web - {F3DCB584-7443-46D4-A95A-05806F42A9CC} 11/21/2019
11/25/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exhibits-PECO CROSS EXHIBITS' is made public 11/25/2019
11/25/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exhibits-COMPLAINTANT EXHIBITS' is made public 11/25/2019
11/25/2019 Document Published on Web - Document 'Exhibits (PECO Ex. BE-1)' is made public 11/25/2019

Public Documents

Document Name Document Type eFiling Confirmation Number Date Received Date Served Reference Docket Number
Preliminary Objection - PECO Preliminary Objection 1627784 4/21/2016
Ans to POs-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Answer to Preliminary Objection 1627784 5/2/2016
Motion to Admit Counsel Thomas Carl Watson, Esq Pro Hac Vice for PECO Motion 1627784 5/11/2016
Cert of Svc of Interrogs & Req Prod Of Docs Set I - PECO Certificate of Service 1627784 5/11/2016
C-2016-2537666 Randall & Albrecht Motion Judge Assignment.doc Other Miscellaneous Document 1627784
C-2016-2537666 Albrecht Randall v. PECO PO Order (3) REV.doc PreHearing Order 1627784
AlbrechtRandall PHO2 C-2015-2537666.doc PreHearing Order 1627784
C-2016-2537666Hearing Notice Hearing Notice 1627784
Letter of Expert Witnesses & Summary of Expert Witness Testimony - PECO Letter 1627784 7/18/2016
Motion to Compel Answers to Discovery - PECO Motion 1627784 8/5/2016
Entry of Appearance-Harvey for Randall & Albrecht Notice of Appearance 1627784 8/8/2016
Cert of Srvc Testimony & Exhibits - Randall & Albrecht Certificate of Service 1627784 8/8/2016
Certificate of Service-PECO Energy Co Certificate of Service 1627784 8/8/2016
Answer to Motion-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Answer to Motion 1627784 8/11/2016
C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht Marino Order Denying Request For Deposition.doc Default Order 1627784
Cert of Service-Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Certificate of Service 1627784 8/15/2016
Joint Motion for Omnibus Schedule Revision - Peco & Complainants Motion 1627784 8/16/2016
Request for Oral Deposition - PECO Prehearing Memorandum 1627784 8/5/2016
Cert of Srvc interrog set I - Randall & Albrecht Certificate of Service 1627784 8/29/2016
Cert of Svc of Answers to Discovery Set I Qs. 1-62 - PECO Certificate of Service 1627784 9/8/2016
Cert of Srvc witness list - Randall & Albrecht Certificate of Service 1627784 9/13/2016
C-2015-2537666 Judge Change.docx Other Miscellaneous Document 1627784
C-2016-2537666 Corrected Judge Change.docx Other Miscellaneous Document 1627784
C-2016-2537666 Cynthia Randall Paul Albrecht v PECO Briefing Extension Heep.doc Order 1627784
Main Brief - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Briefs 1627784 9/26/2017
Cover Pg & Certificate of Service to Main Brief - Complainant Certificate of Service 1627784 9/28/2017
Main Brief - PECO Energy Co Briefs 1627784 10/24/2017
Reply Briefs - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Reply Briefs 1627784 11/6/2017
Cert of Srvc - Reply Brief of Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Certificate of Service 1627784 11/6/2017
Reply Briefs - PECO Energy Co Reply Briefs 1627784 11/13/2017
C-2016-2537666 Randall-Albrecht v PECO Protective Order-Heep.docx Order 1627784
C-2016-2537666 NON- PROPRIETARY ID SEC LTR.doc Secretarial Letter 1627784 3/20/2018
Pet for Ext Time to File Exceptions - Povacz Petition for Extension of Time 1627784 3/22/2018
Letter request 20 day extension to file Exceptions - Stephen Harvey Letter 1627784 3/23/2018
Secretarial Letter-Grants Extension of Time for Exceptions-C-2015-2475726 - C-2016-2537666 - C-2015-1475023-March 2018-Sunstein Murphy Randall and Albrecht and Povacz v PECO Order 1627784 3/26/2018
Petition for Extension of Time to File Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Letter 1627784 4/20/2018
Secretarial Letter-Grants 2nd Extension of Time for Exceptions-C-2015-2475726 - C-2016-2537666 - C-2015-1475023-April 2018-Sunstein Murphy Randall and Albrecht and Pova Secretarial Letter 1627784 4/27/2018
Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Exceptions 1627784 5/14/2018
Letter - PECO Not Filing Exceptions Letter 1627784 5/14/2018
Reply Exceptions - Cynthia Randall & Paul Albrecht Reply Exception 1627784 6/4/2018
Opinion and Order - 2537666-OSA - 5-9-19 PM - Exceptions - Cynthia Randall and Paul Albrecht v PECO.docx Order 1627784 5/9/2019
Exhibits-PECO CROSS EXHIBITS Exhibits 1627784 9/27/2016
Exhibits-COMPLAINTANT EXHIBITS Exhibits 1627784 9/27/2016
Exhibits (PECO Ex. BE-1) Exhibits 1627784 12/6/2016